Reaction Torque from an Ice Auger (2024)

  • Forums
  • Engineering
  • General Engineering
  • Thread starteralkaspeltzar
  • Start date
  • Tags
    IceReactionTorque

In summary, the reaction torque is the torque that is applied by the operator to the auger frame to keep the head from spinning.

  • #1

alkaspeltzar

354
37
TL;DR Summary
Trying to determine what torque a user has to provide to keep the head of an auger from spinning.

Trying to determine the reaction torque a person would have to supply to keep the auger head from spinning when the ice auger is drilling a hole
So I am an ice fisherman and I got thinking, when you drill a hole with an ice auger, the head always wants to turn opposite of the auger bit. You have to apply a torque to overcome the reaction torque. What is that reaction torque? Assuming steady state, auger is already drilling and up to speed, no acceleration, is it equal and opposite torque of the auger bit?

To figure this out, I drew myself a simplified problem with motor and input gear direct drive, say 1inch radius. Then the driven gear is 5 inch radius. The torque applied from the motor is 10lb-inches, created by a 5 lb couple. Auger bit is firmly on ice cutting.

If I sum the torques about B I get:
Tmotor=10 in-lbs, Treaction on driven gear=50in-lbs, Tmotorreaction= -10 in lbs, Tdrivengear=-50 in lbs. The motor torques cancel out. Leaving there the 50 in lbs on the auger bit, and a 50 in lbs torque back on the housing/user. Is this correct?

Also, what force/torque keeps the motor from spinning CCW about A? I assume the 10lbs force at the driven gear at the distance of 1 inch balance out the reaction torque there?

Thank you for the help

Reaction Torque from an Ice Auger (1)



Reaction Torque from an Ice Auger (2)

  • #2

russ_watters

Mentor

23,403
10,722

alkaspeltzar said:

Assuming steady state, auger is already drilling and up to speed, no acceleration, is it equal and opposite torque of the auger bit?

Yes, but only on average. From my vast experience of watching one get used once, 30 years ago, they tend to "catch" on the ice and judder like a hammer drill, so the torque is not constant.

  • #3

alkaspeltzar

354
37

russ_watters said:

Yes, but only on average. From my vast experience of watching one get used once, 30 years ago, they tend to "catch" on the ice and judder like a hammer drill, so the torque is not constant.

Only thing I don't understand, is what force and lever arm creates the torque that keeps the motor from spinning?

So as the motor applies torque to the drive gear, that would make the motor revolve around A, but that doesn't happen. What torque am I not seeing? See picture below. You can assume the motor and gear share same footprint/diameter and that their are directly connected via shaft. Motor ultimately is connected to the auger frame.

Attachments

  • IMG_20201222_143918_01.jpg

    29.7 KB· Views: 156

Last edited:

  • #4

Baluncore

Science Advisor

2023 Award

15,328
9,152

alkaspeltzar said:

What torque am I not seeing?

The operator applies a torque to the auger frame that is equal and opposite to the torque of the auger in the ice.

  • #5

Baluncore said:

The operator applies a torque to the auger frame that is equal and opposite to the torque of the auger in the ice.

I understand that, but I am curious what torque overcomes internally the motor reaction torque so it doesn't want to spin around itslef. See above

  • #6

Twigg

Science Advisor

Gold Member

893
483

alkaspeltzar, the motor's stator is rigidly connected to the frame that the user is torquing. The rotor is on bearings and connected to the drive gear.

Edit: oops, I should've paid more attention to the pictures and noticed it's not battery powered but gas powered. Baluncore covered it correctly below.

Last edited:

  • #7

Baluncore

Science Advisor

2023 Award

15,328
9,152

The auger shaft is connected to the output shaft of the gearbox.
The gears rotate in a gearbox that is bolted to the motor, which is held by the operator.
The side forces on the shaft bearings (crank and gears) provide the couple that becomes the torque.
The gas pressure generates a force between the piston and cylinder head that is converted to a torque by the crank and gearbox.

  • #8

russ_watters

Mentor

23,403
10,722

alkaspeltzar said:

Only thing I don't understand, is what force and lever arm creates the torque that keeps the motor from spinning?

Torque is torque. It's a conserved quantity. The lever arm is irrelevant if you already know the torque.

I understand that, but I am curious what torque overcomes internally the motor reaction torque so it doesn't want to spin around itslef.
[separate]
So as the motor applies torque to the drive gear, that would make the motor revolve around A, but that doesn't happen. What torque am I not seeing?

I guess I'm not sure what you are saying here. The motor (stator) doesn't spin around the rotor because you are holding onto it, applying an anti-torque to it, to hold it in place.

  • #9

alkaspeltzar

354
37

russ_watters said:

Torque is torque. It's a conserved quantity. The lever arm is irrelevant if you already know the torque.

I guess I'm not sure what you are saying here. The motor (stator) doesn't spin around the rotor because you are holding onto it, applying an anti-torque to it, to hold it in place.

I was trying to see how the torque balances all the way thru, such that the motor doesn’t move, but the whole engine/gearbox/frame relative to the auger.I think i figured it out, as i was counting the motor torque twice and confusing myself.

During steady state, all the torque provided by the motor to the input gear is canceled by the matting gear. That force causes the whole head to have a torque of 60 in-lbs in my problem. But the auger motor also received a reaction torque of 10inch pound, making the overall remain torque 50 in lbs.This proves that the torque felt by the operator is equal to the auger drill torque. And that all internal forces/torque balance out.

  • #10

Dr.D

2,412
722

In order to understand the way the torque is transferred through the machine, draw a complete FBD for each element in the power transmission path. This will show you exactly what balances what.

alkaspeltzar

354
37

Dr.D said:

In order to understand the way the torque is transferred through the machine, draw a complete FBD for each element in the power transmission path. This will show you exactly what balances what.

essentially i did that and put it together. but it was a lot more math and makes asking thequestion confusion LOL

  • #12

Dr.D

2,412
722

Would it be better to just attribute the total reaction to the fairies? That seems like the best alternative if the FBD approach is unsatifactory.

  • #13

alkaspeltzar

354
37

Dr.D said:

Would it be better to just attribute the total reaction to the fairies? That seems like the best alternative if the FBD approach is unsatifactory.

probably, but my brain likes to make things harder. THat is why i come here, you guys are a good double check

  • #14

sophiecentaur

Science Advisor

Gold Member

29,408
7,091

Dr.D said:

Would it be better to just attribute the total reaction to the fairies? That seems like the best alternative if the FBD approach is unsatifactory.

Not all of us are familiar with using a FBD and it's very easy to leave out the relevant forces.

alkaspeltzar said:

What torque am I not seeing?

The only torque that you need to worry about is the torque that could cause the mount to spin round on the ice, with you hanging onto it. Your feet are the anchor. The force your feet need to apply will be reduced by the ratio of the auger radius to (the radius of those handles plus the distance from the handles to your feet).
I would imagine that the radius of the auger and the handle distance will have been selected (designed) to get it right. If the auger suddenly sticks then you would either stall / slip a clutch on the drive or be spun round. How slippery is the ice when you start the operation?

  • #15

alkaspeltzar

354
37

All, I did draw a picture, FBD, with all the relevant forces and torques.

If you look above you'll see originally I showed how the motor creates a torque on drive gear A, which then thru the contact forces causes a torque on auger gear B.

MY questions was how does the overall operator feel only 50lb-inches of torque to keep the entire assembly from spinning(based on my easy numbers) and trying to understand all the internal forces/torques thru the gear.

Correct me if i am wrong, but as drive gear A produces 10 lbs of force at 5 inches on drive gear B, that creates 50lb-inches of torque to the auger. This causes a reaction force of 10 lbs back on drive gear A, which cancels the input torque on A, plus causes the force couple to be unbalanced and if you sum the forces about B, creates a torque of 60lb inch. HOWEVER, this is all connected to the chasis at the pivot points and the motor applies an opposite reaction torque of 10lb-inches, so overall, after everything cancels out, there is 50 lbs-inches of torque that the operator has to provide to make the drilling effective.

Essentially the engine torque cancels out, leave the output to the auger of 50lb-inches. And with gear trains, if there is 50lb-inches going out, the operator HAS to provide the equal torque.

  • #16

berkeman

Mentor

68,082
21,631

Thread closed temporarily for Moderation...

  • #17

berkeman

Mentor

68,082
21,631

An off-topic conversation has been deleted. Thread is re-opened.

  • #18

alkaspeltzar

354
37

berkeman said:

An off-topic conversation has been deleted. Thread is re-opened.

Berkeman, can you review post #19 and tell me if you agree? I see you liked my previous comments, i tried to be more clear and am just looking for verification at this point. Thank you

  • #19

berkeman

Mentor

68,082
21,631

alkaspeltzar said:

Berkeman, can you review post #19 and tell me if you agree? I see you liked my previous comments, i tried to be more clear and am just looking for verification at this point. Thank you

I think you mean post #15 now that the off-topic posts have been deleted. I'll let others who are more familiar with your thread comment for now. Reaction Torque from an Ice Auger (4)

FAQ: Reaction Torque from an Ice Auger

1. What is reaction torque from an ice auger?

Reaction torque is the force that is generated in the opposite direction of the rotation of an ice auger. It is caused by the resistance of the ice and the weight of the auger, and it is necessary for the auger to effectively cut through the ice.

2. How does reaction torque affect the performance of an ice auger?

Reaction torque plays a crucial role in the performance of an ice auger. Without enough reaction torque, the auger will not be able to cut through the ice effectively. On the other hand, too much reaction torque can cause the auger to become difficult to handle and can also put strain on the motor or engine.

3. What factors can affect the amount of reaction torque produced by an ice auger?

The amount of reaction torque produced by an ice auger can be influenced by several factors, including the size and weight of the auger, the type and sharpness of the blades, the speed of rotation, and the hardness of the ice being drilled.

4. How can the reaction torque of an ice auger be measured?

The reaction torque of an ice auger can be measured using a torque wrench. This tool allows you to measure the amount of force being applied to the auger as it rotates. It is important to regularly check the reaction torque to ensure that it is within the recommended range for the specific auger being used.

5. Are there any safety precautions to consider when using an ice auger with high reaction torque?

Yes, it is important to always use caution when operating an ice auger with high reaction torque. This includes wearing appropriate safety gear, such as gloves and eye protection, and being mindful of the auger's movements to avoid injury. It is also important to follow the manufacturer's instructions and use the auger on a stable surface to prevent accidents or injuries.

Similar threads

Torque Balance of Motor and Transmission

    Replies
    12
    Views
    2K

    Calculating Torque for an Auger-Powered Ball Pushing Application

      Replies
      2
      Views
      7K

      Torque Reaction Force of Transmission and Drivetrain

        Replies
        10
        Views
        13K

        Torque created around offset wheel

          Replies
          8
          Views
          2K

          Thought problem: torpedo with a drill

            Replies
            7
            Views
            2K

            What are the key calculations for designing an ice hockey puck launcher?

              Replies
              16
              Views
              6K
              • Forums
              • Engineering
              • General Engineering
              Reaction Torque from an Ice Auger (2024)
              Top Articles
              Latest Posts
              Recommended Articles
              Article information

              Author: Stevie Stamm

              Last Updated:

              Views: 5559

              Rating: 5 / 5 (80 voted)

              Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

              Author information

              Name: Stevie Stamm

              Birthday: 1996-06-22

              Address: Apt. 419 4200 Sipes Estate, East Delmerview, WY 05617

              Phone: +342332224300

              Job: Future Advertising Analyst

              Hobby: Leather crafting, Puzzles, Leather crafting, scrapbook, Urban exploration, Cabaret, Skateboarding

              Introduction: My name is Stevie Stamm, I am a colorful, sparkling, splendid, vast, open, hilarious, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.